First up, the size of the light source in relation to the size of the subject.
Imagine looking out the window at the front yard and without seeing the sky knowing whether it is sunny or cloudy. We do know, right?
We don’t have to see the sky to know if it is sunny or cloudy, we can tell from the way the light is behaving on the subjects in our yard. The car has a deep shadow below it if it is sunny and very little shadow at all if it is cloudy.
The plants are either casting long shadows or seemingly no shadows. The sun makes everything have a shadow, while the cloud cover acts as a shadow reliever.
We know this because we have observed the world for our whole lives and we understand how light works when it is sunny and when it is cloudy.
The sun is a tiny light source. (Yes, science nerds it is way huge, but I am talking about from where we look at it.) No more than a coin in the sky.
That is a very small light source. And it can be totally blocked out by the smallest of items: a branch, or a rose, or even a butterfly. That means that the light cannot go around the subject and is instead blocked by the subject.
Here is the equivalent of the sun in the studio. A small, unmodified light at a distance from a coffee cup.

And here is how the shadow falls on a small coffee cup when a very large light is applied. The light wraps around the coffee cup because the light is so much larger than the subject.

That is how the sun works as well.
The sun is the very small light source, and when the clouds come over the land, the sun lights the back of the clouds and they light the earth with no shadows because they go from horizon to horizon. Light is wrapping all around all the subjects it is seen by.

Think of your softbox as a “cloud cover” for your light (the sun) and it makes more sense to you.

Question: is a 4’x5′ softbox a large softbox or a small softbox?
The answer is compared to what? Other softboxes? Yes.
The subject? Well – that depends. What is the subject?
If the subject is a Hot Air Popcorn Maker, then it is indeed a very large light source.
If our subject is a jetliner, then no – it is not a very big light source at all.
And then… how far will it be from our subject?
Distance makes the perceptual size of the light source diminish as it gets farther away. And it is that perceptual view is the one that matters.
A 20″ light source very close to a 1″ watch is a large light source. A 72″ x 72″ source far away from a 14′ square box is a small light source.
And the light will render that way as well.
LIGHT DOES THE SAME THING EVERY TIME – IT IS THE SUBJECTS THAT CHANGE THE GAME
ASSIGNMENT FOR THIS CLASS:
- Choose a subject less than about 8″ – like a shoe or a water bottle. Light it with a small light source (speedlight) to see how the shadows fall. Then light it with a softbox (24″ or so) in close. Very close.
- Move the softbox 6″ away and take another shot. Then do it again at 6″ intervals until the softbox is 6 feet away. Notice the changes in how the subject responds to the light, and how the shadows get sharper and deeper.
The size of the light source in relationship to the subject is one of the four principles of light.
Hey Amazon… REALLY? Are You Kidding Me?
WHAT THE FUCK?. "On March 18, 2014 Amazon Technologies, Inc. (an operating subsidiary of Amazon.com, Inc.) obtained a United States Patent (8,676,045) for a “Studio Arrangement” and a “method of capturing images and/or video.” ibook-store-widgetMany photographers will...
My Favorite Film Cameras and Film Choices
We do so many cool things in P52 and this idea is one a lot of the photographers are picking up on. We are going to have a fun little 'assignment' to shoot 24 frames of film in May. Just 24... but we want all of them to be 'good shots'. What started as a one shot per...
“Air” by Meggan Joy Trobaugh
At the Project 52 2014 group, the assignment was "Air". There were many wonderful submissions. This one by Meggan Joy Trobaugh was exceptional I thought. She carefully planned out the work and made the elements for the final work with a previsualized image already in...
A Fall Workshop in the Canyons Announced
The workshop is a blast. We all pile into a large, comfortable van and head off to Northern Arizona. Our first night is in Flagstaff, then off to the reservation lands of the Navajo, Vermillion Cliffs, Marble Canyon, Kaibab Plateau and more. We spend an afternoon and...
“Black Angels” – An Assignment for a CD Cover
This week the Project 52 PROS for 2014 are working on an CD album cover for a faux assignment. The music is George Crumb's "Black Angels" for Electric String Quartet. It is very challenging music. The students for this morning's Friday class really knocked it out of...
A Life, A Lifetime, and a Tie
John Thomas Banta had over 200 ties. Most were bold, loud, occasionally whimsical and always hard-to-miss. In short, they were very much like him. He dressed for occasions, often wearing his wildly interesting ties. And he lit up the room with his presence. He was a...
Is Giving One’s Images Away for Free a Brilliant Marketing Move?
... or a very very bad idea? Trey Ratcliff (Lost in Customs) has always given his images away on the Non-Commercial Creative Commons License. What is new today is his link to grab ALL of his favorite 500 images for free and download them in full high res form. See...
“What Should Photographers Charge in 2014?” – A Discussion with Rosh Sillars
My bud Rosh Sillars' recent article on "What Should Photographers Charge in 2014?" really hit home with me and a lot of my Project 52 PRO's. Pricing and figuring out what to charge is always a very difficult part of starting a photo business, and Rosh takes a very...
Shooting a Beer with Rui Bandeira
We have so many talented people in the Project 52 PRO group. Meet Rui Bandeira. He shared this shot with my last night and I knew I had to share it with you all. Here is Rui: "Hi, I had 3 goals for this shot: 1) it had to be fresh and make the viewer desire to drink...
Photoshop Repair: Bri in the High Desert
I like to play around in Photoshop a lot, and when I do I am going to start sharing what I do with my Project 52 Pros. And anyone else who wants to know what I do. I am not putting myself out there as a Photoshop Guru by any stretch of the imagination. I am simply...
WHY I AM CHUCKING ALL MY GEAR AND RETURNING TO SAND PAINTING AS MY VISUAL MEDIUM.
I have always loved sand. When I was a kid I would play in it, except when mum let the cat play in it first, and then it smelled sort of like my little brother, but... I digress. Cameras are obsolete. We hear every day about this new gizmo and that new gizmo, and how...
Project 52 Summer Group Opens For Registration
More Information on this page.
Book Ideas: “What If…”
What if. What if you created a magazine instead of a book? Told a story or two in the magazine, showed a subject in depth, then printed 10 copies for influential art directors in your town and offered all who came to the site a PDF? (Blurb does magazines for as little...
ISLA: A New Book by Ernesto Bazan, Photographer
"No, I don’t [do assignments]. I stopped doing that, more or less, when I decided to become a teacher in 2002. Because of my workshops, I had to leave Cuba in 2006, which is ironic. I fund all my work thanks to the generosity of my students. This will be the third...
What Is The Biggest Problem with Your Photography?
The biggest problem may also be the one that most people focus on. No pun intended. "So let’s get the elephant out of the bag most of you keep it in and into the room where we can discuss it: most people are complaining about their cameras because otherwise they’d...
Photographs = Communication = New Creative
Photographs as communication. The new uses of photography continues to grow. "It’s not that my memory improved but, instead, that I started archiving these events and ideas with my phone, as photographs. Now, if I want to research the painter whose portraits I admired...
Omaha
I have been asked by Christopher Tierney to come out to Omaha for a workshop. I have not done workshops for a while, but I really like the midwest and look forward to spending some time there. REGISTRATION PAGE IS NOW READY. For more information, please click on the...
Documentary Photography with a Fresh Twist
PHOTOGRAPH BY MICHAEL DAVID FRIBERG Michael Friberg and Benjamin Rasmussen find a fresh way to explore the conflict in the Middle East. Part reportage, part editorial, they create a powerful new way of communication on a contemporary problem. “The way that we shoot...
The Last Project 52 Assignment for the 2013 Group
"Cooking With Chili" is the name of the faux cookbook. The assignment was to shoot to the layout. The students did a magnificent job with this, and I want to share the work with you all. You can see the layout, and it was provided as a layered PSD file to the...
Irene Liebler’s “Cooking With Chili” BTS Work
Irene Liebler is a photographer/designer in Connecticut. She is also a Project 52 member and has developed quite a unique style. This is a recent image for an assignment on P52, a "Cooking With Chilis" Cookbook Cover, shot to layout. In this post, she walks you...
Art And Its Detractors
"How has your art been received in your community? Do you have any detractors?" "Oh, yeah. That comes up all the time. If you really, really commit to something, someone will hate you for it. And that’s ok. But the further you pursue your art, and the more you come to...
“NO” versus “YES” – Which Got The Most Response?
On the previous post I mentioned, almost in passing, how negative articles and stories are more highly engaged than are positive ones. A few minutes later, this catches my attention: Just Say NO "So, one answer to my student’s rhetorical question is “Just say NO.” As...
On Change Changing What was Changed…
... or something. My friend Jan Klier (NYC) and I were discussing the recent Getty move to grant access to millions of images for only a byline. He feels it is a good move for photographers, and while I am still somewhat ambivalent we both agree that the worst thing...
Chocolate: Two Shots
Photographer David Price shows us two ways to light chocolate. In the first shot, he is using a very large light source. The source is above and behind the chocolate, and that masks the individual color of the items. This is because the specular - the reflected light...