First up, the size of the light source in relation to the size of the subject.
Imagine looking out the window at the front yard and without seeing the sky knowing whether it is sunny or cloudy. We do know, right?
We don’t have to see the sky to know if it is sunny or cloudy, we can tell from the way the light is behaving on the subjects in our yard. The car has a deep shadow below it if it is sunny and very little shadow at all if it is cloudy.
The plants are either casting long shadows or seemingly no shadows. The sun makes everything have a shadow, while the cloud cover acts as a shadow reliever.
We know this because we have observed the world for our whole lives and we understand how light works when it is sunny and when it is cloudy.
The sun is a tiny light source. (Yes, science nerds it is way huge, but I am talking about from where we look at it.) No more than a coin in the sky.
That is a very small light source. And it can be totally blocked out by the smallest of items: a branch, or a rose, or even a butterfly. That means that the light cannot go around the subject and is instead blocked by the subject.
Here is the equivalent of the sun in the studio. A small, unmodified light at a distance from a coffee cup.

And here is how the shadow falls on a small coffee cup when a very large light is applied. The light wraps around the coffee cup because the light is so much larger than the subject.

That is how the sun works as well.
The sun is the very small light source, and when the clouds come over the land, the sun lights the back of the clouds and they light the earth with no shadows because they go from horizon to horizon. Light is wrapping all around all the subjects it is seen by.

Think of your softbox as a “cloud cover” for your light (the sun) and it makes more sense to you.

Question: is a 4’x5′ softbox a large softbox or a small softbox?
The answer is compared to what? Other softboxes? Yes.
The subject? Well – that depends. What is the subject?
If the subject is a Hot Air Popcorn Maker, then it is indeed a very large light source.
If our subject is a jetliner, then no – it is not a very big light source at all.
And then… how far will it be from our subject?
Distance makes the perceptual size of the light source diminish as it gets farther away. And it is that perceptual view is the one that matters.
A 20″ light source very close to a 1″ watch is a large light source. A 72″ x 72″ source far away from a 14′ square box is a small light source.
And the light will render that way as well.
LIGHT DOES THE SAME THING EVERY TIME – IT IS THE SUBJECTS THAT CHANGE THE GAME
ASSIGNMENT FOR THIS CLASS:
- Choose a subject less than about 8″ – like a shoe or a water bottle. Light it with a small light source (speedlight) to see how the shadows fall. Then light it with a softbox (24″ or so) in close. Very close.
- Move the softbox 6″ away and take another shot. Then do it again at 6″ intervals until the softbox is 6 feet away. Notice the changes in how the subject responds to the light, and how the shadows get sharper and deeper.
The size of the light source in relationship to the subject is one of the four principles of light.
What I’ve Learned So Far; Seventeen; “Funk In, Funk Out, Funk Off”
I know that being a professional photographer should be a bed of roses, a magical place where unicorns and rainbows are interspersed between the Bentleys and mansions. A place where creativity is simply something that everyone has in spades, and no one is ever without...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Sixteen; “Devil’s In The Details / Don’t Sweat The Small Stuff”
Two old sayings people like to throw around a lot without really listening to what they are throwing around; "The devil is in the details" means pay very close attention to the minutiae... it is where the challenges will be hiding. "Don't sweat the small stuff" means...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Fifteen; “Own Your Set” – Or Be Prepared for Chaos
As a commercial and advertising photographer, one of the most important responsibilities you have is to be in control of your shoot. It can mean the difference between a very successful shoot and one that gets by. (Keep in mind there are no failures - it isn't an...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Fourteen; “Rolling With The Punches While Dancing On a Wire”
One of the challenges of commercial photography is that you are obligated to hit a home run every time your number comes up. You are the clean up hitter, or the "go to" guy when the team needs a guaranteed win. It can be a little stressful at times. Like standing on a...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Thirteen; Life’s Too Short for Asshats
You know, it really is too short for most things. Life. Four letters, and yet it means so much to our very souls. One of the things I loved about being a photographer was all the amazing people that I got to meet. I photographed the guy who invented the mechanical...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Twelve; “Nice Shot… Who Cares?
Back when I was first starting out in this business, I shot nearly every day. Maybe for an hour or two, maybe only for a few minutes. When I wasn't shooting, I was in the darkroom developing film, making contact sheets or printing. Lots of printing. There was a lot to...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Eleven; “They Don’t Pay Me Enough To…”
Have you ever heard someone say this? "They're not paying me enough to do my best work." Possibly some variation of that? What a terrible, awful, self-defeating way of doing anything. It's an amazingly stupid, self-absorbed sense of entitlement that brings nothing but...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Ten; Listen to Your Gut
... it knows what the heck is going on. That place deep inside you where you just know something is not right. Listen to that feeling. It is right more than it is wrong. Now I know that your head will be arguing with you the whole time. There is a reason for that is...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Nine; Loyalty Should Be a Brand Attribute
I am a pretty strict believer in loyalty. I live it and I demand it. Not in harsh, 'kingly' sort of way, but more of a gentle 'I am way too busy for your call' way. I can list loyalty as one of my strong traits. I may sometimes be loyal to a fault. I have always felt...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Eight; Life – Through a Lens…
... is different - depending on what lens you choose. Choose wisely. One of the joys of photography is being able to use a different lens for a different perspective. Something very far away can be brought 'closer' by a long (telephoto) lens. We can add depth to a...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Seven; Gear Envy Sucks
Gear envy takes two major forms; 1. "I can't do what I want with this crummy gear." 2. "I can't believe that guy/gal has such great equipment when their work sucks so bad." Actually envying someone by what their gear collection is - "I so wish I was him, I...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Six; Self Sabotage and the New Photographer
(This is an ongoing series that I am writing for the month of December, 2014. After nearly 40 years in this business, I have learned a couple of things. I am sharing that knowledge here.) What is "self-sabotage"? It is the premature destruction of a talented...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Five; Step Up, or Step Aside
In photography, as in most things in life, there are moments when you hesitate for reasons you may never know. Those small hesitations can be driven by fears, or unknowing, or simply because you had too many beers and are partially paralyzed from playing some...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Four; You Can’t Please Everyone
Not only can you not please everyone, you shouldn't even try. Why? Because all those "anyone's" can't even agree what they like anyway. The first seven or eight years of my photographic career were spent trying to figure out what "they" wanted to see. Should I have...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Three; It Ain’t Brain Surgery
When I first started I met a photographer who was what I call a "prima-donna", or asshat in today's world. He would rant and rage while shooting. All of his assistants would cower as he belittled them, humiliated them and treated them less than anyone should ever be...
What I’ve Learned So Far: Two; Partners Maybe – Maybe Not
There is nothing better than a great partner. Finding someone who fills in those blanks in your business acumen can be a life saver. Whether it is a rep, or a second shooter/first assistant, or a full business partner, working with someone who helps you stay focused...
What I’ve Learned So Far: One; Photography Ain’t Easy
Starting today and for the duration of December 2014, I will be making one post per day on ideas and thoughts I have had about this business of photography. And it is directed toward the professional practice of commercial photography. I have been kicking around in...
Thinning Down, Weeding Out… Hopefully
Gettin’ Skinny and Lovin’ It I bet you're wondering if this will be about a new diet program, and how I am slimming down and getting to be a lean mean fighting machine. And it is… sorta. It’s a diet of all things photography. I am moved out of the big studio I share...
Industrial Assignment: Project 52 Pros
One of the most under-rated and least mentioned genre of commercial photography is Industrial/Corporate. It isn't sexy, and models don't flock to the studio after hours. The travel is usually not to some awesome resort or fancy hotel, but rather to out of the way...
Photographing Mundane Subjects
I have always been a ‘commercial’ photographer. While that included some wonderful editorial and fashion along the way, the bulk of my income was from good old commercial photography. Photographs made for advertisements, brochures, product sheets, illustrative uses...
The Summer 2013 Project 52 Yearbook (Free Download)
Proud to announce the arrival of the Summer 2013 Project 52 Pro Yearbook. If you would like to purchase a hard copy, it is available at cost at Blurb. PROJECT 52 PROS SUMMER 2013 YEARBOOKbyDon Giannatti | Make Your Own Book If you would like to download a free screen...
What If The Problem Is That You Suck?
Photo of the author by Mike Eller Even More Advice for the Aspiring Professional Photographer. These days a lot of people seem to be offering advice in the area of becoming a full time professional photographer. Some of those folks like Greg Heisler, Jay Meisel, Gail...
“Money, Money, Money” A Difficult Subject
The subject was money. And the assignment was for a brochure cover for a financial services company. Layout was included, but optional. The important thing was to not be totally cliche' about the image, and also not to succumb to a boring shot. This is a most...
Are We Clear About What We Do as Photographers?
Are We? Two things recently formed today’s article. One was a note from a commercial shooter who was being setup to fail, and the other from a consumer shooter angry that the client kept wanting more and more retouching… and feeling trapped that it must be done. To...